My board and executive work began in the public sector, higher education and not-for-profit organisations, and has since taken me from top ten pharmaceutical companies to start-ups and into venture and private equity-backed businesses, each with a very different model of ownership and governance.
Joining Charity People’s Board and Leadership practice to focus on the charity and not-for-profit sector feels like something of a return, though familiar terrain looks quite different through broader frames of reference.
Much of that shift in perspective comes from having seen how governance is built in each of these models, and where the weight of accountability rests. A listed pharmaceutical company operates within a framework of shareholder accountability, market scrutiny and regulatory oversight. Investors in a private equity-backed business often have a more direct influence on strategy and governance. A public body works within a statutory framework that may involve accountability to ministers, Parliament, regulators and the public. None of these arrangements tells the whole story of an organisation, but each shapes board discussion, how decisions are made and whose interests are considered.
Since taking up my new role, I have noticed a certain word arise repeatedly among colleagues and in conversations with partners: stewardship. Stewardship, as I understand it in governance, means taking responsibility for an organisation’s purpose and resources on behalf of others, including its beneficiaries, the wider public and those who will follow.
Stewardship vs oversight
Oversight asks whether an organisation is being run properly: whether money is accounted for, risks are managed and the executive is held to account. Stewardship encompasses all of this, but asks something further: whether the organisation is being kept in good health for the people it exists to serve, now and in future. Stewardship is exercised by trustees individually and through the board collectively, and trustees can discharge their oversight duties diligently, yet still fall short as stewards if purpose, or ultimate impact, slips out of sight.
Charity trustees carry responsibility for stewardship in a particular way: purpose is set out in the charity’s objects; public trust underpins its income and reputation; and trustees are de facto custodians of a structure designed to outlast them. Decisions on reserves, partnerships, risk and leadership are therefore taken on behalf of people who may never see them, including those the organisation has yet to serve.
Informing the board’s judgement
Acting in the interests of beneficiaries requires a board to understand those interests well. That understanding reaches the board through executive reports, performance data, committee discussion and the knowledge trustees bring themselves, and the weight given to each source shapes the decisions that follow. Financial, legal and professional expertise tends to carry authority by default, particularly in discussions of budgets, risk and compliance. Direct knowledge of how services are experienced, including the lived experience some trustees bring, can be drawn upon less readily, even when it bears directly on whether a decision will work in practice.
Neither form of knowledge is a substitute for the other. Professional expertise can show whether a decision is sound, lawful and sustainable, while lived experience can show whether it makes sense to the people it affects. Boards are better placed to exercise stewardship when both inform their judgement and neither is treated as a token.
What this means for appointments
This has practical consequences for how trustees and senior leaders are appointed. Skills matrices remain useful, but they describe what a person knows rather than how they will contribute. Appointment processes should also explore behaviours: how someone listens, how they challenge, how they share information and how they use the influence that comes with expertise or status. A highly qualified trustee who dominates discussion can weaken a board.
A recent Treasurer briefing brought this into focus. Having strengthened its foundations, a partner charity explained its need for a Treasurer who could provide strategic oversight of a largely restricted funding model. Technical expertise was a sine qua non, but so was the ability to communicate accessibly, so that every trustee, no matter their background, could understand the financial choices before the board and contribute to them with confidence. While financial knowledge is a form of power in the boardroom, it takes a good Treasurer to share it.
Three questions before a new appointment
1. What does the organisation need this person to help the board understand, challenge or decide over the next few years?
2. Whose perspectives are already well represented, and whose are missing or carry less weight?
3. How should this person use their expertise and influence, and how will the process test this?
Much of our work lies in helping boards answer such questions before setting out to find candidates. An appointment may be intended to fill a gap, strengthen a capability or support a new direction, and clarifying that purpose at the outset allows it to buttress the search throughout.
These are initial reflections, and I expect them to develop. I would be interested to hear how others experience these areas. How does your understanding of stewardship influence the way your board thinks about its composition, skills and leadership?
+447708 401653

Recent Comments